Movie Analysis:
"The
Blair Witch Project"
and "The Sixth Sense"
Review by Katharine
E. Monahan Huntley
The Blair Witch
Project, co-writer/director/editors Eduardo Sanchez and Dan Myrick's
faux documentary about an urban legend, has created its own mythology.
The least of which is its tremendous financial success-a phenomenon
sure to be recounted among aspiring filmmakers for years to come.
As a horror story,
the scare factor is not as startling as one might expect. At least not
when you are aware of how the cinema verite' was really produced. Certainly
not when you're watching the film knowing full well one of its stars
is appearing on Letterman that night. In spite of this, its realistic
intensity and wild popularity indicate there's something about the Blair
Witch.
Survival of the
fittest is one take on the story-issuing forth a potential Dramatica
grand argument. Student director Heather Donahue is the main
character. Capturing the Blair Witch essence on 16mm is the objective
story goal. Heather's crew, Josh and Mike, represent the obstacle
character's (dissenting) point of view once the quest goes awry-which
is almost immediately. The conflict and eventual disintegration between
Heather and the boys is delineated in the subjective story. The
outcome is a chilling success, however, the judgment
is not just bad-it is horrific.
The Blair Witch
Project may not be a Dramatica grand argument in the strictest sense.
Nonetheless, it is a finely crafted work of filmic fiction and I, for
one, am superstitious enough to stay out of the woods and in my hotel
suite-room service and a concierge my essential camping necessities.
The
Sixth Sense is another ghost story, but unlike The Blair Witch
Project the ghosts are visible (along the lines of Dickens' restless
specters) and the Dramatica grand argument story quite distinct.
Writer/director M. Night Shyamalan performs a neat mind trick upheld
by sharp storytelling that, upon replaying the narrative, answers all
pertinent questions.
The opening sequence
outlines the impetus for Dr. Malcolm Crowe's (main character)
drive. A renowned child psychologist, his past (mc concern)
is visited upon him with a violent suddenness (objective story driver-action).
A former patient, grown up and still anguished, puts himself out of
his misery by shooting Malcolm and then committing suicide. The good
doctor did not understand (os story concern) the nature
of his demons.
The next fall, the
psychologist finds himself diagnosing an acutely sad and suspicious
(obstacle character unique ability) young boy whose problems
(desire) are uncannily similar-offering Malcolm a chance for
redemption (judgment-good). Malcolm and Cole Sear conceptualize
(subjective story concern) a way (limit-optionlock) to
help each other, and in turn help others understand (os goal)
the troubled child's gift.
The four throughlines
are uncommonly well balanced. The main and obstacle characters are fully
developed. Although Malcolm and Cole's interactions in the subjective
story are the film's focal point, the roles the main and obstacle characters
fulfill as objective characters in the overall story are clearly
defined and key to the story's resonance-particularly exemplified by
Cole's triumphant acceptance (oc resolve-steadfast) of his abilities
(oc solution).
"Out of the
depths I cry to you, oh Lord." An otherworldly plea treated with
compassion in this fine Dramatica grand argument story, transforms The
Sixth Sense from a "freak" show to one of benevolent humanity.
Story engine settings
for THE
SIXTH SENSE.
|